Difference between the Malthusian Theory and the Optimum Theory of the Population


Malthusian Theory of Population in following terms.

(i) Malthus is pessimistic and afraid of an increase of population. But the optimum theory is optimistic because it holds that an increase of population may increase the productivity of the country. An increase of population is welcomed so long the actual number is less than optimum.

(ii) Malthus considers the problem of population in relation to the food stuffs of the country only. But optimum theory considers it in relation to the total wealth of the country. A country may be short in her food stuffs, but she may be rich in other resources. Great Britain produces only a part of her necessary food-stuffs. But she can meet her shortage by selling her industrial products and various other services such as banking, shipping etc and by importing food from abroad.

(iii) But the defect of the optimum theory lies in the fact that there is no means to determine the optimum number of a country. Moreover optimum for a country is not fixed. With the change of data i.e. resources the optimum also changes. For example if Pakistan possesses optimum number today, and if tomorrow she discovers some new mines or oil fields, the optimum number of today may be under- population tomorrow. Conversely with the loss of a good market for cotton etc the optimum population may be turned into over population.

Thus theory is not very useful in practice because by a plan or policy we can not achieve the optimum. The actual population may coincide with the optimum only as accident.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is the Dynamic Theory of Profit

Image
Clark's Dynamic Theory of Profit And Its Criticism The Dynamic Theory of Profit is associated with the name of an American Economist, J. B. Clark. In the world of reality, according to J. B. Clark, profit arises only in a dynamic economy. An economy is said to be dynamic when there is a change in population growth or change in the method of production or a change in the consumer’s wants, etc. A society which is without these changes is called a static society. In a static society, only monopoly profits continue to exist. All other economic profits are gradually eliminated by competition. In a dynamic society, an entrepreneur is always confronted with continuous unpredictable changes in demand for his product. The variation in demand may take place due to changes in fashions, tastes, the standard of living, distribution of income, population, new inventions, international repercussions, technological advances, etc. A prudent entrepreneur will always keep an eye on future demand
Read more

Compare the anatomy of Bifacial and Isobilateral leaves

BIFACIAL LEAF: It is also called dorsiventral leaf. This leaf is more strongly illuminated on upper surface than on lower surface. This unequal illumination induces a difference in the internal structure between upper and lower sides. Its internal structure shows: (1)        Upper Epidermis This is single layer of cells with thick cuticle which checks excessive evaporation of water from the surface. It does not contains chloroplasts, stomata are also absent. (2)        Lower Epidermis This is also single layer but with a thin cuticle. It bears many stomata, two guard cells of which contain some chloroplast, none are present in the epidermal cells. Internal to each stomata is large cavity called respiratory cavity. Lower epidermis of leaf is meant for exchange of gases (oxygen and carbon dioxide) between the atmosphere and the plant body. Excess water also evaporates from lower epidermis. (3)        Mesophyll The ground tissue lying between upper epidermis and th
Read more

osmoregulation in terrestrial and aquatic animals

Mechanism of osmoregulation is very important for all groups of animals whether inhibting land or water. Unlike plant cells, animal cells when placed in hypotonic solution burst due to the continuous absorption of water. On the contrary they would shrink and die if constantly placed in hypertonic solution. Normally uptake and loss of water are in balance for proper survival of cell. (1)        Osmoregulation in terrestrial animals: Terrestrial animals are more likely to loose water by evaporation through their permeable surfaces exposed to amsophere. Among various animal groups only Arthropods and vertebrates became the most successful land dwellers. They have developed number of strategies to maintain osmoregulation of their body fluid. (a) Water proof external coverings: To prevent water loss through external surfaces, vertebrates like reptiles, birds and mammals have water proof keratinized epidermis. Similarly the insects have developed external water proof layer called
Read more