Limitations of Audit and Objects of Auditing
Audit in spite
of having valuable advantages has a number of vital limitations, namely:
1. Vital aspects like finances, business
ethics, managerial efficiency and effectiveness are not dealt with by audit.
2 clever
manipulation of books and records, etc, are not disclosed by audit.
3. Since audit of books does not tell the
whole story additional information, clarification and explanation is to be
sought to form an audit opinion.
4. Audited accounts may not mirror correct
position due to faulty judgement of the auditor.
5. Audited accounts may lack authenticity
as the external evidence may not be wholly reliable.
6. Audit techniques employed for
collection of evidence may not be consistent with the nature of businesses.
7. Audit does not provide proof of certain
representations.
8. Certain organisations cannot bear the
cost of audit examination.
9. Since auditor is not expert in all
fields he may rely upon the opinion of other experts e.g. engineers,
architects, values, legal advisors.
10. Though under the law shareholders appoint
auditors but in fact the directors appoint them, so there is no independence of
auditors.
11. The explanation and information given by
the client may not be correct and may affect the audit opinion.
12. Accounts are prepared on a number of
judgements depending on such factors which may not remain constant.
objects of Auditing [B. Com]
Ans: The following chart exhibits at a glance
the objects (or purposes) of auditing.
The objects (or
purposes) of auditing can be classified into two broad parts:
1. Primary a. Opinion Reporting on financial
statements.
2. Secondary b. Detection and prevention of errors.
c. Detection and
prevention of fraud.
(a) Opinion as
regards financial statements:
According to
ISA-1, the objective of an audit of financial statements is to enable the
auditor to express an opinion whether the financial statements are prepared in
all material respects, in accordance with an identified financial reporting
framework. Section 255 of the Companies Ordinance requires a company auditor to
state whether in his opinion – (a) the balance sheet gives a true and fair view
of the state of company’s affairs as at the end of the financial year; and (b)
the profit and loss account gives a true and fair view of the profit or loss
for the financial year. In other words the main purpose of auditing is the
expression of auditors opinion, adherence to accounting principles, consistency
and conformity thereto and the fairness with which the statements present the
financial position and operating results.
(b) Detection
and Prevention of Errors:
One of the
incidental objective is to detect the errors occurring in the books and records
of the enterprise. Whatever be the nature of error it is bound to affect either
the trading results or the financial position or both. Consequently, the
financial statements would not reflect true and fair position. Detection of
errors can be achieved by a thorough examination of all the entries and
financial records.
Prevention of
errors must follow detection of errors. This can be achieved by instituting
both physical and moral check. The knowledge of the fact that accounts will be
audited will put moral influence over client’s staff and they will be more
cautious and careful in their work. This will prevent errors to a great extent.
ISA11 provides
standard, guidance and auditor’s responsibilities to consider the risk of
material misstatement resulting from errors.
(c) Detection
and Prevention of Fraud
Detection of
fraud is another important object of auditing. The auditor should keep in mind
the possibility of frauds while auditing. If he suspects its existence he must
probe unto its roots and unearth or discover it.
Prevention of
fraud can be achieved by a system of internal check. If such system is
defective, suggestion be made for its improvement. Auditing itself indirectly
exercises moral influence over the fraudulent intentions by creating a fear of
being found out. In addition method of internal check introduced through
auditing limits the possibilities of fraud.
Comments
Post a Comment